

Professor Picklebottom
Sink or Float?
Explore why some objects sink while others float, even when they look the same.
This experiment reveals how density determines whether something stays on top or sinks below.

Ages
7-12 yrs
Duration
min
Difficulty
Medium
Stage
Stage 2-3
Cite this resource
Created by Darin Carr (BSc, DipEd)
NESA Accredited Teacher · Chemistry & Physics Specialist · 30+ years in-class teaching
Resource Version: 1.0
First Published:
Last Updated:
1 Mar 2023
21 Aug 2026

MISSION VERIFIED
Classroom tested. Teacher designed. Safe at home.

Designed by Darin Carr (BScDip Ed)
Practising NESA accredited
Australian Science Teacher
★ 30+ years of classroom experience
MISSION PROGRESS
20
young scientists have completed this mission.
I'VE COMPLETED THIS MISSION
Click to let us know you have completed this mission
LATEST TEACHER FEEDBACK
No feedback yet for this experiment. Use it with your class and let us know how it went!

Before you investigate... watch the mystery
MISSION HOOK
Professor Picklebottom and the team are travelling and collecting amazing science mysteries.
✔ Coming in Term 1 2027

KEEP EXPLORING
Curiosity Files
BIG Questions & Discovery
Illustrated Facts
Explore • Discover
Road Trip Science
Discover science everywhere
The Teacher's Cauldron
Think. Experiment. Inspire
Books
Read • Explore
Videos
Watch & Learn
LAB Resources
Premium learning resources

Mission Equipment
Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
4–5 clear test tubes (or small clear glasses)
Water
Sugar cubes
Small potato pieces (same size if possible)
Spoon or stirring stick
Test tube rack (or something to hold them upright)

Let’s Investigate
Follow the missions steps below to solve the mystery.
1
Big Title

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
1
Big Title

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
1
Big Title

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
1
Big Title

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
1
Big Title

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
1
Big Title

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
1
Big Title

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
1
Big Title

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
1
Big Title

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
1
Set Up Your Tubes

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
1
Set Up Your Tubes

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
1
Big Title

Gather your materials and get
ready for an amazing mission!
PREDICT
OBSERVE
EVIDENCE
ASK
SAFETY
TIP
PREDICT
The Crazy Scientist LAB Learning System™
Every experiment follows The Crazy Scientist Lab Learning System™ — a simple way to help kids think like real scientists.
We
-
LINK to what they already know,
-
ACTIVATE curiosity through hands-on discovery
-
BUILD understanding that actually sticks.

If you dissolved a huge amount of sugar into water, do you think something that normally sinks might start to float?
Could the same object behave completely differently just by changing the liquid it's in — not the object itself?
What do you think would happen if you kept adding more and more sugar?

Watch carefully… something strange is happening
The potatoes are the same — but they don’t behave the same
Some sink… some float… some hover in the middle
What’s changing… and what’s staying the same?

This is how the Dead Sea works — it's so salty that people float without even trying to swim. It's also why freshwater fish can't survive in the ocean (the salt concentration pulls water out of their bodies).
Engineers use the same idea to design submarines: pump water into the ballast tanks to sink, pump it out to rise — changing the density of the vessel, not its shape. If you could change the density of any liquid you wanted, what problems could you solve?
"Want the full teacher guide? The Crazy Scientist Lab includes classroom delivery tips, how to manage the WOW moment, differentiation for Stage 2 & 3, — ready to teach tomorrow."
Think Like a Scientist
Scientists don't stop after their first discovery.
They ask new questions, collect more evidence and test their ideas in different ways.
Where could you take this investigation next?
What happens if you use different materials of the same size?
What happens if you change the water (e.g. add salt)?

Dr Puddledrip’s Science Tip

Read the Science
The potato didn't change. The water did. And that changes everything.
Fresh water has a certain density — a certain amount of stuff packed into every drop. A potato is just a little bit denser than fresh water, so it sinks. Not by much — but enough.
Now dissolve salt into that water. The salt packs extra mass into the same space, making the water heavier without making it much bigger.
The water's density creeps up... and at some point it overtakes the potato. Suddenly the potato floats.
Did you notice the water looks completely identical in every tube? You can't see the salt. You can't smell it. But the potato knows. It's reading the density of every liquid and responding perfectly every time.
And here's the really wild part — get the mix just right and the potato doesn't sink or float. It just hovers. Perfectly still. Suspended in the middle like it's weightless.
Scientists call that neutral buoyancy — and it's exactly how fish stay at the same depth without swimming, and how submarines dive and surface without using their engines.
A potato just taught you how a submarine works.
But how does a fish change its depth whenever it wants — without fins, without effort?
You can see the same density principle at work in [The Imposter] — where a raw egg does exactly what your potato did — and in [Coke Density], where the difference between sugar and artificial sweetener creates a floating surprise with two identical-looking cans.
The answer is one of the cleverest things in nature. Find out in The Crazy Scientist Lab!
Teachers & Homeschoolers: Print-ready HD versions of this Science Behind It poster and companion G&T Challenge Card are available inside The Crazy Scientist LAB.
Scientist's Challenge
Designed for HPGE, gifted learners and children who enjoy an extra challenge.
Teachers & Homeschoolers: Print-ready HD versions of this Science Behind It poster and companion G&T Challenge Card are available inside The Crazy Scientist LAB.
The Next Question...
You've solved today's mystery. Now discover where curiosity can take you next.
Teachers & Homeschoolers: Print-ready HD versions of this Science Behind It poster and companion G&T Challenge Card are available inside The Crazy Scientist LAB.
Vocabulary
Density — How much mass is packed into a certain volume.
Buoyancy — The upward force a liquid exerts on an object.
Displacement — When an object pushes liquid out of the space it occupies.
Know a parent or teacher who'd love this? Send it on! 👇
Keep Exploring This Mystery
One experiment leads to even more amazing discoveries inside the Learning Universe.
Curiosity Files
BIG Questions & Discovery
Illustrated Facts
Explore • Discover
Road Trip Science
Discover science everywhere
The Teacher's Cauldron
Think. Experiment. Inspire
Books
Read • Explore
Videos
Watch & Learn
LAB Resources
Premium learning resources

- Coming Early 2027
How Does a Can of Diet Coke Act Like a Fish?

- Coming Mid 2027
How Can a Giant Cruise Ship Float Like a Duck?
Ready for Your Next Discovery?
READY TO TEACH THIS
TOMORROW?

Running the experiment is easy; however, teaching it well is another challenge.
Teachers often ask:
How do I adapt this for Stages 1,2 or 3?
What misconceptions will they have?
What syllabus outcomes does it cover?
What do I do with fast finishers?
How do I structure this for a full class?
What do I say when they ask WHY?
BUILD AROUND THE LAB LEARNING SYSTEM™
Every resource is designed using our teaching framework.

Inside The Crazy Scientist LAB
Everything you need to confidently teach science tomorrow.






Opening early 2027. Join the Founding Member Waitlist
More Ways to Explore The Crazy Scientist World
Discover more hands-on science fun, programs and resources for every curious mind.












